Wednesday, April 27, 2011
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Example learning blog
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
Monday, April 18, 2011
Monday, March 14, 2011
Thursday, March 03, 2011
OF WHICH?
I received the following question from a student, which I'll respond to below:
I quoted the following sentences from Guardian, though, I could not understand what the expression "of which" means here
"There's the predictable slew of buzz-building reports overnight, the most unlikely of which comes from the usually infallible" and on other occasion " Apple will also add a few surprises, the most dramatic of which would be retinal display.
And this from comments " the only value of which is the capacity to store all my music"
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/pda/2011/mar/02/ipad2-apple-steve-jobs
MY RESPONSE: Good question. Let's answer it in two stages:
Firstly, the purpose of WHICH in these examples is to join together two sentences. So:
I found an interesting article. I would like to ask you a question about the interesting article.
becomes
I found an interesting article WHICH I would like to ask you a question about.
So far so simple, but, here's the second stage of my answer. What if one of the sentences we want to join has a preposition?
I saw a horrible clip on Youtube. In the clip, an owl gets injured at a football match.
My grandfather had six brothers. Five of my grandfather's brothers fought in the Second World War.
become
I saw a horrible clip on Youtube in which an owl gets injured at a football match.
My grandfather had six brothers, five of whom fought in the Second World War.
Note that the preposition is attached to WHICH in the relative clause. When we attach a preposition to WHO, it becomes WHOM
So, in your examples:
"There's the predictable slew of buzz-building reports overnight, the most unlikely of which comes from the usually infallible" and on other occasion " Apple will also add a few surprises, the most dramatic of which would be retinal display.
= There's the predictable slew of buzz-building reports overnight. The most unlikely of the reports comes from the usually infallible…(I suspect that what comes next is the source of the report)
and: Apple will also add a few surprises. The most dramatic of the surprises would be retinal display.
Your second example tells me why you found it difficult to understand. You have clipped out the important part of the sentence that WHICH refers to:
And this from comments " the only value of which is the capacity to store all my music"
I had a look by myself and found this:
I'd much prefer a 128GB iPhone. Then I could finally retire the iPod Classic, the only value of which is the capacity to store all my music.
= I could finally retire the iPod Classic. The only value of the iPod Classic is the capacity to store all my music.
Does that make sense?
Tuesday, February 08, 2011
Monday, February 07, 2011
Thursday, February 03, 2011
Exemplification : A Hot Potatoes Quiz
Click here for an ugly-looking Hot Potatoes Quiz I made as a form of feedback on student writing.
Wednesday, February 02, 2011
Noun phrase construction
STUDENT QUESTION
this sentence:
Due to the increasingly (adj) globalised (v) business (n) environment (n)....
Why? do you understand my question?
If I want to express the same meaning, I will write like this:
Due to the increasingly global business-environment...
MY RESPONSE
Actually your version is OK. The hyphen between business and environment isn't necessary, but the difference between GLOBAL and GLOBALISED is just that the latter (GLOBALISED) suggests that forces have MADE the world global.
Your analysis of the phrase from the text isn't quite right though:
We could argue about whether business is an adjective or noun here and it doesn't really matter either way, but GLOBALISED is definitely not a verb. A lot of adjectives in English are formed from the active or passive form of a verb. To me, this is quite useful because it helps you understand their meaning (i.e. whether they are active or passive). Examples include bored, boring, interested, interesting, satisfied, satisfying, and I'm sure you could add hundreds more to my list!
A question about commas
Student question
I have a question about "if" and commas.
What is the differet between this two sentences.
1 I would get married, if I were you.
2 I would get married if I were you.
My response:
The comma does make a slight difference. A comma tells a reader to pause, and it separates out parts of a sentence.
Sentence number 1 encourages the reader to stress IF. Stressing IF makes what follows seem less likely, or in this case, emphasises the fact that "I am not you".
There are other occasions when commas will make a much bigger difference to meaning. Can you see a difference between these two sentences:
1. I like student who email me questions about grammar.
2. I like students, who email me questions about grammar.
Monday, January 24, 2011
Sufficient evidence?

Last week I asked my class the following question about this chart (taken from The Economist's Daily Chart online feature) :
Do you think these statements are TRUE or FALSE? Do you have enough evidence to verify each statement?
1. DVDs are cheap in China because they are all illegally copied.
2. The average Polish employee has to work longer than the average Indian employee in order to be able to afford a DVD.
3. DVDs are cheaper in Germany than in India.
4. The best films are made in France.
5. The currency used in Australia is dollars.
6. People in Japan like to watch DVDs.
7. The average US worker can earn enough money in 200 minutes to buy 4 DVDs.
Together we agreed that 2 and 7 are true, 3 is false, and we do not have sufficient evidence to comment on the other 4 statements. The students then wrote statements about other charts. Please comment on whether their statements are true, false, or impossible to comment on without further information.
Big Mac Index

US Border Control

1. The cost per apprehension of illegal immigrants was steady between 1992 and 2000.
Read-e for the masses

1. The line graph shows the sale of e-books in 2008 and forecasts growth from 2009 to 2011.
Foreign Students in America

1. Do you think the percentage of British people who go to study in America is lower because they have English as their first language as well?
Countries with most installed wind power

1. China produces more wind power than Spain because China owns a greater proportion of the world.
Africa Cup of Nations

1. There are more African football players in France than in Germany.
